Would you invest in a bank if:
Total core income, led by net interest income, was turning around (up 13% quarter-on-quarter)?
Expense growth is increasing at only about a third of the group income increase above?
And group loans:deposits are just over 100% suggesting a lending book that is not too stretched?
Most large banks listed on the markets today are struggling with at least one of the three criteria above, so it may come as some surprise that the above graphics concern the National Bank of Greece, the largest listed Greek bank.
NBG shares are up 6%+ in Athens on this news which also included the following headline takeaway:

Of course things hardly remain sweetness and light. The company still is reliant for a good chunk of the funding behind the attractive loan:deposit ratio on European Central Bank funding and the tier 1 capital is only just above the 9% level regulators want
And even though Greece is now - post provisions for bad loans etc - breakeven on a profit/loss perspective for NBG, you have to still worry about an economy where unemployment is just so bad (as per the figures released today, see below) and all the talk remains of further assistance:
Greece had the highest rate of unemployment in the European Union with 27.6 percent in May, according to data released on Friday by the EU's statistical authority Eurostat, confirming data compiled by the national statistics agency ELSTAT, and adding that youth unemployment was also at a record high in May of 62.9 percent.
So one only for extreme traders who hope that Greece doesn't leave the Euro/go bust/descends into deeper financial issues?
Well, there is one other angle which is the company's Turkish business. Not only profitable but 18% return on equity and the highest capital ratio in the Turkish banking business. Turkey has had its own issues in recent weeks - with a volatile Turkish Lira and concerns about the country's trade deficit - but applying a 40% discount to a fair value for the company's Turkish equity base of Euro6.6bn ((1.8 * Euro6.6bn) * 0.6) gives a value of around Euro7.2bn. And the market cap of National Bank of Greece today? Euro7.3bn...
So Greece (and their breakeven Southern European operations) essentially for free?
Now many questions remain...uppermost is that potential new losses/writedowns/write-offs in Greece could dwarf Turkish value/worth. If I was the NBG though I would look into creating value for investors by spinning off the Turkish unit and letting investors decide. Far better to do this under your own steam then being forced to do it in more extreme times. Over to you management.
Final chart - unsurprisingly NBG shares are kicking around their lows (Athens quote chart below):
An extreme trade but worthy of some further investigation. It is surprising what you can find when you look at a situation 99.9% of investors complete ignore.





Thanks for your breakdown on NBG, Chris. Turnaround plays are my favorite stock angle. Happy to be an owner for the long haul. Strongest technical support level on a chart I've ever seen!
ReplyDelete