Markets do change
quickly, that is their nature. There was
a report in yesterday’s Financial Times
with the headline ‘A busy summer looms for Neelie Kroes, the European telecoms
regulator,
who is trying to save an
industry “near collapse” with plans for a “real telecoms single market” ‘. Then
over the last 24 hours we hear chat about two potential telecom deals.
The first deal is fairly
straightforward. Vivendi is in talks to sell its Maroc Telecom stake. For most Vivendi watchers this will come as a
blessed relief – assuming it comes off – and this should return the stock to
the Euro17.5+ price level which is closer to its fairer value. Vivendi has a range of assets above and
beyond Maroc including Activision in gaming, GVT in Brazilian rural broadband,
Universal Music and a range of French-centric assets such as Canal+ in pay TV
and SFR in French mobile. They really
need to unbundle more of these but if the media reports are true (and there
have been a lot of reports over the last few months but this one appears more
serious) Vivendi shares should go up today.
The second deal is a bit
more complex. Yesterday afternoon, news
broke that Spain’s Telefonica was in
advanced talks to buy KPN’s German
business E-Plus for about US$8bn. There would be some element of
cross-shareholdings complicated by the fact that Telefonica Deutschland – the German unit of Telefonica – was itself
partially spun-off by the Spanish group earlier this year.
The deal was
well-received yesterday (KPN shares up 11%, Telefonica Deutschland shares up
over 6%) and superficially the deal – almost as long mooted as some aggressive
restructuring of the Vivendi portfolio of assets – makes sense, creating the
biggest market share (although not service revenue) player in the German telecoms
market. It would also make the German
market much more of a three player market (with Vodafone and Deutsche
Telekom). This is generally good for margins for all
players.
You can see the
competitive match-up. It is a good fit
in theory.
The terms of the deal
has just been announced:
Euro8.1bn EV for deal
X9 anticipated 2013
ebitda of E-Plus
KPN retains a 17.6%
value in the combined entity which by my rough estimates would have a value of
around Euro15-16bn. Call it a Euro2bn+
stake value.
The new entity is hoping
for Euro5-5.5bn+ of synergies. Telefonica
bought E-Plus on a premium to its own value of c. x7 ebitda.
They need to get the synergies to really make the deal work. The trouble is that whilst Germany has always
been perceived as an attractive market, like many European telecoms markets,
profits have not been going anywhere fast. This is from the Q1 Telefonica
Deutschland presentation for example:
Today’s E-Plus results
from KPN show lower profits year-on-year due to ‘higher customer acquisition
and marketing costs’.
I also note that the
anticipated FY13 E-Plus ebitda was around Euro900m. Q2 ebitda was Euro275m. This company is not growing.
If we generously put the
combined E-Plus/Telefonica Deutschland at Euro2bn this year, a zero growth
entity would be valued at x6 ebitda (at least you can manage it for cash). That’s Euro12bn. If they get Euro5bn of synergies that gets
you up to Euro17bn in value. Well today
we are in the Euro15-17bn range. On that
basis we maybe have 5-10% upside and – of course – time value of money to
consider. It will take time to get these
synergies.
Let’s think about KPN
quickly. Euro7.6bn market cap
today. After they apply the monies for
E-Plus above debt goes to around Euro4.5bn.
And they have that useful Euro2bn new German entity stake above
too.
EV will be around
Euro12bn (Euro7.6bn + Euro4.5bn circa).
Using the Q2 numbers ebitda for the Benelux businesses is around
Euro760m. They will do well to keep this
flat. Annualise this and you get
Euro3bn+. X4 ebitda is a bit rude but
maybe right given the numbers will probably decline. Some of the other support
elements are better given the net debt: ebitda of x1.5 and that they hope to
restart a dividend next year. To me though,
the upside is that Euro2bn+ worth stake in Telefonica Deutschland/E-Plus new
entity.
On this basis I get a
new share price target for KPN of Euro2.27, 26% above the current share price…although
to put it another way: where the share was at the end of last year!
In summary I think the market has factored in quite aggressively even
synergies from the E-Plus/Telefonica Deutschland deal and upside is not that
exciting to me. By contrast KPN has got
a lifeline from this deal. The share has
upside if you accrue a value to its ongoing holding in the E-Plus/Telefonica
Deutschland entity. To me that’s much
more interesting risk-reward. I will
watch the KPN open today and consider a position so long as there is good
upside to that Euro2.27 target price.
No comments:
Post a Comment