Pages

Sunday, 28 July 2013

Business never sleeps - Siemens, Publicis and Omnicom

The weekend is always a good chance for reflection upon events of the last five business days.  The other aspect is the time to anticipate upcoming events.  Later on I will be posting my inaugural weekend news review which, I hope, will draw from both elements.

Sometimes events occur and this weekend we have had two of note.  Fortunately neither are communique appraisals from a Head of Government/Central Banker conference...

We talked about Siemens last Thursday following their shock trading update where they updated the market to the news that they would not be hitting their margin targets.  The brief notification on Thursday appeared to make some mention of the impact of global economic conditions and it was this aspect that we wrote up and commented on.

Saturday, however, bought more specific personnel news with this comment by the company:

'At its meeting on July 31, 2013, the Supervisory Board of Siemens AG will decide on the early departure of the President and CEO.  In addition, it will decide on the appointment of a member of the managing board as President and CEO' 

So Peter Loescher is to go.  That is a shame for him personally but an inevitable move in my opinion.  Siemens' results execution had been a bit sub-par over the last year and I remember noting at the last set of quarterly numbers in May that they even highlighted the various margin/performance gaps with peers such as GE.  The pressure has risen to a point where a change has to be made.

In an organisation the size of Siemens it is comical that one man should be expected to singularly make the difference but that is the figurehead role of a CEO.  As a potential Siemens shareholder though the comment I did not want to hear was that a member of the managing board is a shoo-in to replace Mr Loescher.  My instinct though is that I would prefer to hear that there was a global search for the best candidate. 

Here is the irony though.  Mr Loescher was the first externally appointed CEO in Siemens' history. 

During the period shown below during which Siemens has - crab-style - moved sideways (in a volatile fashion), GE shares have risen by over 70% (everything expressed in US Dollars). 


I would like to say that it was time for some different thinking in Munich, but my feeling is that the struggles of Mr Loescher were a little out of his control and that we should look, as an explanatory factor, the culture and reactions of the company, as well as the global economy.  

 

The second story that broke over the weekend shows the value of the oligopoly.  I am finding that I keep on mentioning this word, so we may as well try to precisely define it.  This is from Investopedia:

An oligopoly is much like a monopoly, in which only one company exerts control over most of a market. In an oligopoly, there are at least two firms controlling the market.

From an investment theme perspective, oligopolies tend to imply better pricing power and barriers-to-entry...and maybe a higher share price rating.

Also on Saturday, two of the largest advertising companies in the world agreed to an all-stock almost merger of equals.  As the chart below shows - taken from the recent WPP AGM report - this is an important transaction as it creates the world's biggest advertising company due to the merger of the number two and the number three. 



The aim of the transaction is not the creation of synergies per se...these are estimated at just US$500m or around 1.5% only of the (using Friday close) market capitalisation of the combined entity.  The rationale for the transaction here is much more client-focused:

 
From an oligopoly perspective this transaction is very good news.  The new combined entity, along with WPP, will be more than twice the size of the new global number three Interpublic (IPG) and
number four, Japan's Dentsu. 
 
This is good news from a valuation perspective.  The Omnicom/Publicis presentation document usefully shows the combined earnings capability.  x11 EV/ebit and over 6% free cash flow yield, using historic 2012 data, seems light to me. 
 
 
 
So logically the whole advertising sector should trade up on Monday - Dentsu will give us our first guidance in Japan.  The question I have though is this: will the combined Omnicom/Publicis combination really have no regulatory issues given the deepening of the advertising oligopoly noted above?
 
More thinking needs to be done on the advertising sector but global investors need to be interested.  
 


No comments:

Post a Comment